Frank Productions, Inc.
Menu
  • External link opens in new tab or window
  • External link opens in new tab or window

Only in America

Column

Directors: Ron Frank
Producers: Ann Benjamin, Ron Frank
Editor: Ron Frank
2003, USA, 72 minutes, English

 -

About the Film


Standing as a witness to the Jewish-American process of emergence, from an ethos of persecution to the threshold of the White House, ONLY IN AMERICA paints a picture of the Jewish-American experience in the latter part of the twentieth century, with Connecticut Senator Joseph Lieberman's campaign and personal history as its centerpiece. "Viva La Chutzpah!" sums up the phenomenon created by a vice presidential campaign in which Lieberman, an unabashedly religious Jewish candidate, crossed over ethnic and religious lines bringing out people of majority and minority backgrounds in record numbers.


Featuring interviews with Lieberman's inner circle-from his wife and his mother to members of Congress such as Dianne Feinstein and John Breaux to New Republic Literary Editor Leon Wieseltier, director Ron Frank tells Lieberman's story from a myriad of positions to construct a critical analysis of the Jewish-American experience, its current impact and its potential for the future. This is a future in which, contrary to the mid-century period wherein Jews believed that visibility made one a lightning rod for anti-Semitism, there is even a possibility that the next president of the United States could be a Jewish one. - AFI Discovery Channel, Silver Docs

Column
https://0201.nccdn.net/1_2/000/000/16a/989/thumb.jpg
0
VARIETY

By KEN EISNER

 

Joe Lieberman's historic 2000 run for the White House works as a vehicle

to examine the relationship between the U.S. and its Jews. Lack of focus

on political philosophy makes "Only in America" safe for PBS and other

pubcasting berths, but updating it with fallout from the contested last

election would make it more relevant.


Senator Joe emerges as a likably self-deprecating yet pious figure. "I'm in this campaign 24/6," he booms, archivally, in reference to refusal to work on Saturdays. (He was the only leading Democrat to call for

Clinton's impeachment, which probably didn't help the campaign.) Sagas of Lieberman's immigrant mother and wife Hadassah, a survivor of the Czech Holocaust, are interesting. Pic looks at Lieberman's rise in the context of American anti-Semitism, which previously had Father Coughlin and other stirrers, and makes a case for concluding that those days are gone forever. The only negative is helmer Ron Frank's lack of interest in understanding the conservative views of a man who, as Jon Stewart recently dubbed him, is "the candidate for people who want to vote for George Bush, but don't find him Jewish enough."

WASHINGTON POST

By JENNIFER FREY


This is the way David Royle, career filmmaker, sees it:


California is all about Hollywood and fantasy.


New York -- where he spent most of his early career -- is all about entertainment.


And Washington is all about gritty reality.


And so tomorrow night's symposium includes screenings of "Only in America," in which Los Angeles director Ron Frank follows the 2000 campaign of Sen. Joseph Lieberman, the first Jewish candidate for vice president, and "We Wuz Robbed,"Spike Lee's analysis of what happened in the 2000 election. The panel that follows-- hosted by ABC political director Mark Halperin and featuring George W. Bushmedia adviser Mark McKinnon and Democratic strategist Eskew -- won't be so much about film as it is faith and politics, and will look at the 2000 election and the upcoming race in 2004.


"It's getting a much bigger play there [in Washington] than anywhere else, which I'm sure is because of the subject," Frank says. "A lot of people think, well, our film's a political film, and it really isn't -- it's a cultural film -- but obviously politics are all over the place on it."


MSNBC

BY HOWARD MORTMAN

"Only in America" is a proud new film looking at Joe Lieberman's historic run for the vice presidency in 2000. Fun, clever and insightful, the 72-minute documentary paints a picture of the American-Jewish experience in the latter part of the 20th century, with Lieberman's campaign and personal history as its centerpiece. For Lieberman -- now running a second time for national office -- it's a great film. But it's also bad timing. The film's central theme may not work again in 2004.

ACCORDING TO a new Quinnipiac University poll, the fact that President Bush and Sen. Joe Lieberman are strong religious believers has little impact on whether Americans will vote for them. Sixty-nine percent say the fact that President Bush is a born-again Christian makes no difference in how they'll vote. And even bigger numbers for Lieberman -- 85 percent say it makes no difference that he's an Orthodox Jew.

That might come as news to Lieberman. Here's what the Connecticut Democrat said on the "Imus" show Thursday: "My faith is an important part of my life, and as it is, I think, for most people in this country, and you know, I'm not going to stifle that part of me because a few people get nervous about it."

JEWISH IDENTITY
For the 2004 campaign, Lieberman still thinks it's a plus, while Americans don't care.  But during the 2000 campaign, as recalled in "Only in America," Jewish identity was front and runner. Lieberman put it there.

He's shown saying things like, "I'm so honored to be the first Jewish American to be given the chance…" And when the film captures a weary Lieberman on the trail, he says, "I know that rest is coming. Sabbath is coming. Thank God." He repeats that sentiment at a tarmac rally: "Thank God for the Sabbath. We rested today. And we're rested and ready to go to the finish line on Tuesday."

During the 1960 campaign, another breakthrough presidential candidate was also scrutinized under the religious microscope. And Catholic John F. Kennedy responded by saying, "Voters are more than Catholics, Protestants or Jews. They make up their minds for many diverse reasons, good and bad. To submit the candidates to a religious test is unfair enough -- to apply it to the voters is divisive, degrading and wholly unwarranted."

LITTLE IMPACT
The good news is, being Jewish doesn't hurt Lieberman, either. A CNN/Gallup/USA Today poll recently asked, ''If the United States elected a president who was Jewish, what impact, if any, do you think it would have on United States foreign policy?" Two-thirds said it wouldn't make much difference.

And Lieberman presciently foreshadowed the Quinnipiac poll by telling the Jewish newspaper ''The Forward" that "Americans are too fair and sensible" to be fertile ground for prejudice. Lieberman said he's been greeted with "real warmth and acceptance" in many different communities around the country. The numbers bear out Lieberman's personal experience.

Then why is it still an issue?  Lieberman told Imus, " I've always believed in the separation of church and state, and you know, I'm going to keep believing in the good lord as well." The truth is, Lieberman will score political points by reminding voters that religion is important to him. Narrowly, his strong religious identity and faith will help him in Southern states, like the all-important early South Carolina primary where Lieberman is well organized. And broadly, Lieberman could rightly be betting that post September 11, people have gone back to religion and houses of religion, and he'll resonate with those voters. Comedian Jon Stewart was onto something when he called Lieberman "the candidate for people who want to vote for Bush but don't think [Bush is] Jewish enough."

NO BLOC VOTING
But again, during the 1960 presidential campaign, JFK told the Ministerial Association of Greater Houston, "I believe in an America … where there is no Catholic vote, no anti-Catholic vote, no bloc voting of any kind."

Is that belief shared by Joe Lieberman? It sure didn't seem that way in 2000, when he worked Florida Jewish voters hard.In current context, Lieberman is best in the film when he says simple things like, "I feel grateful to have been born American. "That's the Joe Lieberman America wants to hear in 2004. MSNBC Terms, Conditions and Privacy ©2003.



Column

Contacts


External link opens in new tab or window276a Heritage Village, 06488, Southbury, Connecticut, United States, US, CT, External link opens in new tab or window818 693-1663, frankprod@earthlink.net

Column

Open Hours


Today
09:00 am - 06:00 pm
Column

Follow Us


  • External link opens in new tab or windowTwitter
  • External link opens in new tab or windowLinkedIn
  • External link opens in new tab or windowPinterest
  • External link opens in new tab or windowInstagram
  • External link opens in new tab or windowClick to edit
close lightbox